France has brought back strict border checks with its six neighboring Schengen countries, raising questions about balancing security with free movement.

Starting November 1st, these checks will last for six months as the government aims to address increasing security risks and illegal immigration.

France implements six-month border controls

For the first time since the Schengen Zone was created nearly 30 years ago, France will temporarily bring back border checks with Belgium, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg, Spain, and Switzerland.

The French government pointed to “serious threats to public policy, public order, and internal security,” including concerns about terrorism and criminal networks aiding illegal migration.

This is the largest reinstatement of border checks in Schengen Zone history, affecting all land, air, and sea routes with neighboring countries.

France’s new Prime Minister, Michel Barnier, defended the move, saying, “The public expects us to have an effective policy to control immigration.”

As these measures began, travel experts warned of possible delays, especially for commuters crossing into France.

Security threats and migration drive new policy

The French government has listed several urgent security threats behind this decision, including increased terrorism risks and the growing presence of criminal groups involved in smuggling and illegal migration.

A major concern is the possibility of radicalized individuals entering through migration flows, which officials say requires tighter border checks.

Interior Minister Bruno Retailleau supports the Prime Minister;s position, stressing the need to remove migrants who enter through illegal routes to strengthen security and keep public order.

In response, rights groups have voiced concerns, arguing that France’s actions may conflict with EU law.

While the Schengen Borders Code permits temporary border checks, they should not last longer than six months unless there is a new and serious threat to public order. 

Critics note that France has regularly imposed such checks since 2015 after terrorist attacks, raising questions about whether these “temporary” measures could become permanent.

(Image courtesy of pawel.gaul via iStock)

Long lines, big impacts

The return of border checks has raised concerns about its immediate effects on commuters, businesses, and cross-border trade. Frequent travelers between France and neighboring countries now face possible delays due to added checks.

Experts already predict longer wait times for those commuting for work, tourism, or trade. Past studies show that border checks can cause delays, impacting tourism and the timely delivery of goods.

These border measures may also strain businesses that rely on smooth trade and travel. Companies in logistics and tourism are likely to face disruptions as movement between France and its neighbors slows down.

In a recent statement, a travel expert warned, “Long waiting times could impact the operations of cross-border businesses and affect workers who rely on free movement for their livelihood.”

EU’s border control guidelines raise questions

EU guidelines encourage member states to limit internal border checks in the Schengen Zone to protect free movement. However, the Schengen Borders Code allows temporary border controls if there is a serious threat to public order or security.

France’s new controls have drawn criticism, with some arguing that Paris may be overusing this exception by frequently citing security risks.

Rights groups argue that France has used this loophole multiple times since 2015, often in response to terrorism or migration concerns. They warn that the current measure could violate the Schengen Agreement, which was created to promote free movement. 

Critics worry that if such controls become routine, they could weaken the Schengen framework altogether.

(Image courtesy of Jill Evans via Pexels)

From open borders to tightened checks

The reintroduction of French border checks adds challenges for both short- and long-term visitors, as well as migrants trying to enter the EU.

Travelers from Schengen countries, used to crossing into France without checks, now need valid ID and should be ready for inspections.

For migrants, this policy could make it much harder to enter France, as the government has stated that those arriving illegally are more likely to be deported.

This change aligns with the upcoming European Travel Information and Authorization System (ETIAS), which will pre-screen travelers from visa-exempt countries before they enter the Schengen Zone.

Although the ETIAS is mainly for non-Schengen citizens, these stricter border controls suggest a shift toward tighter movement regulations within the EU.

With France and Germany leading these efforts, migrants and travelers may face more restrictions when moving across Europe.

A united front?

France’s renewed border controls will likely impact EU immigration policy more broadly. 

French authorities are pushing for stricter EU immigration laws, with Interior Minister Retailleau calling for a coalition of EU countries to strengthen control at the bloc’s external borders.

This reflects a Europe-wide shift toward tougher immigration and asylum policies, as more countries aim to reduce illegal migration.

The policy highlights growing tensions within the EU over balancing security with humanitarian needs in migration management.

While the Schengen agreement supports open borders, France’s actions show the limits of this ideal when security risks are a concern.

This approach aligns with other European leaders who advocate stronger external borders and tighter checks to protect internal security, potentially shaping future EU immigration policy discussions.

Balancing security and free movement

France’s return to border controls marks a major change that could impact the future of the Schengen Zone.

By reinstating these checks, France is putting security ahead of the EU’s core principle of open borders. This raises important questions about balancing free movement with national security, a debate that will likely grow as the EU faces new security challenges.

With these temporary measures lasting six months, many will watch closely to see how this affects daily commuters, migrants, and the precedent it sets for other EU countries.